Welcome to the wonderful world of legislation. German politician
Otto Von Bismarck allegedly asserted that "If you like
laws and sausages, you should never watch either one being made."
Despite his admonition, How A Bill Becomes A Law will
tempt fate by looking behind the scenes at the legislative process
in Congress.

Processing solutions to societal problems
into legislation is the key function of Congress. There is often
little agreement on the problems government should tackle and
less agreement on the most desirable proposed solutions.

We typically think of individual members of Congress as the
people who identify problems and propose solutions. While it
is true that only a member of the House or Senate can formally
introduce legislation, the ideas come from many sources (see
Exceptions
to the Rule).

Whatever the origin, members of Congress and their staffs draw
up the formal legislation, attempting to avoid unanticipated
consequences and conflicts with existing law. A bill can be
introduced in either chamber by a congressman or senator (except
for revenue
bills which, according to the Constitution, must go to the
House first).

Both houses of Congress are too large for efficient, detailed
analysis of legislative proposals. Most of this work is done
in committees. Committees specialize in particular policy areas.
Legislation is referred to the most appropriate committee or
committees by the chamber leadership (see House
Versus Senate). Committees may kill, amend, or support legislation.

Even committees are too large and diverse to handle complex
legislation, so proposals are sent to subcommittees specializing
on specific topics. Subcommittees call in experts to testify
on proposed legislation. Sub-committees can kill a bill by not
recommending it to the full committee, amend it , or pass it
on in its initial form.

Members iron out the final details on a piece of legislation
in a mark-up
session during which the legislation is gone over line by
line. Supporters suggest amendments (see Strategies
and Power Plays) in an attempt to create a coalition of
supporters large enough to get sub-committee, committee, and
chamber approval. A bill usually dies without subcommittee approval.

Subcommittees report legislation to full committees, which
may pass them on as presented, suggest amendments, or kill them
by inaction or a negative report. Committees may carry out a
full set of hearings themselves, or rely on the hearings held
by their subcommittees.

The differing sizes and traditions of the House and Senate
show up clearly in scheduling legislation. The smaller Senate
works much more informally, with the Majority Leader consulting
with the Minority Leader and proposing a schedule to be approved
by unanimous consent.

Debate in the House and Senate is the culmination of months
(and sometimes years) of effort by proponents to shepherd the
bill through the previous stages and to line up support. The
actual debate can be disappointing; most of the members' minds
are already made up. Often few members are on the floor to hear
the debate, since those taking part are talking more to their
constituents and providing their rationale of legislative
intent.

HOUSE: Congress expresses its wishes formally through
voting. House votes are usually done by voice or by using the
electronic voting machines into which each member places an
I.D. card and votes "yes,""no," or "present".
Electronic votes are displayed on a panel behind the presiding
officer.

Both the House and Senate must pass legislation that is identical
in every way before it is sent to the president for approval.
After each chamber has passed its version, the legislation is
sent to a conference committee made up of leaders of the originating
committees to work out the differences. At times, each chamber
instructs its members as to what to accept or reject.

Once the president receives a bill, he has ten days to decide
whether to approve or veto
it. Approved bills are signed by the president, often in a public
ceremony including the bill's key supporters.

The use of the plural "processes" is intentional.
The legislative process is complex and intentionally redundant
with multiple players having to make decisions in parallel fashion.
It is inherently a set of political processes, in which individuals
seek to gain support for policy preferences whose value generally
cannot be proven, only asserted. Persistence and hard work by
committed politicians are required to steer legislation through
the formal stages in the process when possible, and when not,
to use alternative routes when available. It is no wonder that
it is easier to block legislation than pass it.

|